What is happening
A hard drive must receive stable power, release or position its heads, spin the platters to operating speed and load internal firmware before the computer can read sectors. USB power loss can mimic a mechanical problem, but stuck heads, spindle damage, impact and internal contamination can create the same sound. A quiet board-level fault may also prevent normal spin. The safest path depends on the drive model, incident history and whether the symptom follows a known-good compatible power path.